Posted by
Prysson on Wednesday, August 23, 2006 9:45:41 AM
Dean Barnett was doing a fine job over at Hugh Hewitt’s blog until he posted this obtuse piece last night. I fear he had too many beers at the golf course.
Here are the few points he made in the piece followed by my comments.
I have a ton of respect for Bernard Lewis. He’s forgotten more about Islam than I’ll ever know. Hell, he’s forgotten more about everything than I’ll ever know (except probably pro wrestling – I bet I have the edge there). But his carefully worded warning fell on deaf ears at the Soxblog household.
…
What made it especially upsetting is that a lot of the most respected and intelligent residents of the blogosphere bought into this silliness.
…
So I was planning on spending the day monitoring the big fat nothing that I knew was going to happen today.
…
these people did our country no favors this week. There are a lot of people desperate to believe all is well and that we’re perfectly safe. These are the people, like highly respected Time Magazine columnist Andrew Sullivan, who think the terror bust in London was a Karl Rove-orchestrated P.R. stunt. Until these people get a grip on reality, we’ll struggle to fight this war successfully, being such a divided society.
We have to win the hearts and minds of our countrymen, too. Today, August 22, was not a positive step in that direction.
I hardly think it is foolish to take the words of one of, if not the foremost scholars on Islam and Islamic history seriously when he suggests that a day might be portentous. Several very serious minded individuals took it seriously as well. I feel no shame in having been anxious about the 22nd and frankly find Dean Barnett’s crowing about being right in being singularly unconcerned not only unseemly, but juvenile, petty and simple.
Personally, I didn't blog on it other than to acknowledge the concern registered by others. I didn’t think it would be rational to go about predicting doom and destruction...it tends to undermine your credibility when it doesnt occur. Much like Hugh Hewitt undermined his credibility when he insisted Harriet Miers would be a grand SCOTUS justice insisting that the senate calculus prohibited a true conservative from getting approved only to have Alito end up on the SCOTUS. (I love ya Hugh but that wasn’t one of your finest hours)
However, I find it equally silly to run around beating your chest after the fact, patting yourself on the back for being certain nothing would have happened. Boy wouldn’t you have looked stupid if something had. Paying attention when a man like Bernard Lewis speaks is hardly something one would categorize as stupid.
Finally, Barnett’s insinuation that those who were concerned somehow damaged the GWOT is completely absurd. At this stage of the game there are those who either believe in the threat or don’t believe in the threat. Merely because one day a threat doesn’t materialize isn’t going to change people's minds who already believe that there is no threat to begin with. And frankly, if someone is going to suddenly think the whole thing is a hoax because less than two weeks after an uncovered bomb plot to blow up planes across the Atlantic some warnings turned out to be nothing, than that person is a fool and lost cause anyway.
Arguing that we should never have a false alarm because they put off silly people like Andrew Sullivan and some how that makes it more difficult for us is just asinine.
I tell you what Dean. You were put off by the whole thing. Fine, but spare me the holier, smarter and all things better than thouism.
This is hardly the first and most certainly won’t be the last time there is a false alarm. People have to be larger than that and wise enough to understand that they will occur. It is far better to be overly cautious than to be not cautious enough even to the point of being cavalier which as I mentioned earlier smacks of a certain juvenile simplicity…but then what more can one expect from a Sox fan.